Lemme try to put my spin on it.... I had one AI experience (was roped into it with friends) Aventura Spa Palace. Compared to my other Playa experience non AI. Based on 2 people.....
AI - $3200
Cabs- $200
total - $3400
Pros - Unlimited booze
Cons - Horrible food - Ambiance.....ummm...no.
2000 inmates hotel wide
Took 20 mins to walk to lobby to get out
The unlimited drinks were not always available for what we wanted
(i.e. call drinks)
No Beach at this particular AI (all rock)
Non AI- $700 per week (or cheaper...place on 5th ave. OR in half moon bay
Akumal)
$1000 booze (high side)
$700 food.... Places like Carboncitas, or other taquerillas/Restaurants
$250 rental car (fully insured)
$60 in gas... (including trips to Tulum and Coba....plus daily playa
runs)
Total - $2700
-$300 no rental car
$2400
Pros - Solitude as far as not being stuck in a massive resort.
The luxury of eating where you want for each meal. Better food.
Get the drinks "I" want
If in PDC... no cabs needed to stumble home
Clubs, Shopping at no extra fee/
time
Cons - Compared to MY AI experience?? Absolutely none
I see where AI's can benefit families for sure! But for an individual or couple???